← Back to Brewed Up Insights
8x

what SEBI demanded to settle, against the penalty it eventually imposed

SEBI's old settlement demands were 8x the final penalties

Markets No. 133 10 November 2026 · 2 min read · By

SEBI's new settlement rules take effect on 7 November 2026. A board paper published in September explains why the rules needed changing. In cases where settlement talks failed over the last 2 years, the amount SEBI demanded was, on average, 8 times the penalty it eventually imposed.

A settlement lets someone accused of breaking market rules pay SEBI and close the case without admitting guilt. The idea is simple: paying to settle should be cheaper than fighting the case. But SEBI's old formula often made settlement too expensive.

Out of 1,576 settlement applications received over 3 years, only 568 resulted in settlements. Another 640, or 40%, were returned, rejected or withdrawn. The old formula also counted wrongful gains twice: first while calculating the settlement amount and then again when the person had to return the money.

The new formula tries to make the amount more predictable. It starts with the minimum penalty prescribed by law and multiplies it based on who is settling. For example, an independent director pays 2 times this amount, while an exchange or depository pays 5.5 times. The stage of the case, previous violations and seriousness of the breach can increase the amount further. First-time applicants must pay at least ₹3 lakh.

This means people can estimate the cost of settling a SEBI case in advance. The amount is still designed to be higher than the normal penalty, but should be more reasonable than before.

People with pending cases, including those whose earlier settlement applications were rejected, get 90 days to apply under the new rules by paying an additional 20%.

SEBI's bet is that more reasonable settlement amounts will encourage more people to settle, instead of dragging cases through lengthy proceedings.

40% of SEBI settlement applications failed in 3 years

What became of 1,576 settlement applications filed with SEBI over 3 years, by count. Fewer settled than were returned, rejected or withdrawn.

SETTLEMENT APPLICATIONS

  • Settled568 36.0%
  • Returned, rejected or withdrawn640 40.6%
  • Not accounted for in the memo368 23.4%
A bar of 1,576 applications split into 568 settled, 640 returned, rejected or withdrawn, and 368 the memo does not account for.

The memo does not say what became of the other 368, 1,576 less the 2 counts it gives.

SEBI board memorandum, September 2026: Review of SEBI (Settlement Proceedings) Regulations, 2018, para 2.4 · 3 years to 2026

SEBI's new settlement price depends on who is settling

Multiple of the law's minimum penalty used as the starting amount, by who applies, from 7 November 2026. An exchange starts at 5.5x, an independent director at 2x.

TIMES THE MINIMUM PENALTY IN THE LAW

Independent director2.0x
Other individual2.5x
Non-executive director3.0x
Promoter or KMP3.5x
Company or fund4.0x
Exchange or depository5.5x
6 bars of the multiplier on the minimum penalty: independent director 2, other individual 2.5, non-executive director 3, promoter, executive director or key manager 3.5, company, broker or fund 4, and exchange, depository or clearing corporation 5.5.

Promoter or KMP includes executive directors and key managers; company includes brokers and funds; exchange includes depositories and clearing corporations. Other factors then scale the amount, never below 1x, with a ₹3 lakh floor for a first-time applicant.

SEBI (Settlement of Administrative and Civil Proceedings) Regulations, 2026, regulation 11(1) · From 7 Nov 2026

Sources